Kidnapped: The Abduction of Edgardo Mortara

Kidnapped: The Abduction of Edgardo Mortara
Date: 04/02/2025 Times: 7:30 pm - 9:45 pm

This film was a nominee for the Cannes Palme D’Or and the César Award in 1923 and, perhaps not surprisingly, it won the Best Film award at the Italian Golden Globes. It has recently been put in the Guardian’s top 20 list for 2024. It is intoxicating, at times nearly overwhelming, thanks to perfect casting, an economical and impassioned screenplay, and filmmaking overseen by 84-year-old co-writer and director Marco Bellocchio, who might be one of the greatest living narrative filmmakers who is not usually recognised as such. If you like a good story, based on truth and brilliantly told, this is one for you.

In 1857 in Bologna, a part of Italy that was then controlled by the Papal States, an infant Jewish boy named Edgardo Mortara is impulsively baptized by his family’s babysitter, a Catholic teenager. By the time the boy turns six, knowledge of the unauthorized ceremony reaches the local inquisitor Father Pier Gaetano Feletti (Fabrizio Gifuni). Feletti sends police to take the boy from his family, citing a Papal States policy forbidding Christians from being raised by members of other faiths. The Mortaras are told that the boy can remain with them if everyone in the household (including Edgardo’s six siblings) converts. Edgardo’s father Salomone ‘Momolo’ (Fausto Russo Alesi) and mother Marianna (Barbara Ronchi) pick a third, agonizingly difficult path: let the boy be taken away and retain their household’s religious and cultural identity while fighting church and state through the legal system and the newspapers, in hopes of returning Edgardo to his birth family and pulling the whole establishment down.

There aren’t many scenarios more fundamentally appalling than the forced separation of children from their parents. Kidnapped builds upon and complicates that sense of violation even as it keeps cutting back to the family pursuing justice. The movie also provokes philosophical questions that exist alongside the fundamentals without making them too academic and extinguishing their fire: What does one do when a kidnapped person says they don’t want to be rescued? If you try to pull them away from their adaptive circumstances anyway, against their will, is that kidnapping? Kidnapped is also an astute study of power: how it’s acquired and maintained and exercised, and how poorly those who have got used to wielding it react after they wake up one morning and realise they’re about to lose at least some of what they’ve got.

Kidnapped: The Abduction of Edgardo Mortara

Year: 2023

Country: Italy

Cert: 12

Duration: 134 mins

Dir: Marco Bellocchio

'A solid, emotionally powerful story.'


Venue: William Loveless Hall